Skip Navigation

Grilled New York Steak

twice-baked potatoes, red wine butter, broccoli
4.2 stars
(696 reviews)
  • Nut-free
  • Egg-free
  • Gluten-free
Certified Black Angus New York steak is grilled medium-rare. Served with a twice-baked potato that is stuffed with mashed potato, sour cream, sweet butter, scallions, and cheese. This steakhouse classic comes with a red wine butter and steamed broccoli.
Ingredients
  • Strip steaks
  • Russet potatoes
  • Broccoli
  • Unsalted butter
  • Red Wine
  • Sour Cream
  • Cheddar Cheese
  • Shallots
  • Scallions
  • Kosher Salt
  • Black pepper
Nutrition
Servings Per Container: 1.0
Amount Per Serving*
Calories 720
Total Fat 35g
Saturated Fat 20g
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 200mg
Sodium 1080mg
Total Carbs 41g
Dietary Fiber 6g
Sugars 4g
Protein 61g
*Our nutrition data includes all sauces, dressings, condiments, and garnishes included with a dish. If you have specific concerns about sodium, fat, or overall calories, know that we often serve these items on the side so you can add them to taste or leave them out, if you like.

What People Are Saying

3 Stars
Steak was tough with too much fat
1 Stars
I followed the heating Instructions and my meat was completely under cook where i thought my food would be warm and ready when I cut into it. Unfortunately, it was pretty much raw so k had to cook it and just eat the half of the potatoes
2 Stars
Not tastey or tender
4 Stars
Loved the potato, broccoli (simple but cooked just right) and the sauce on the steak. The steak itself was too fatty for my taste. That rich sauce would be wonderful on a leaner cut. Please offer the potato and broccoli as sides!
3 Stars
It was ok, but expected more for $19. Main thing is my steak didn't look like the photo... It was thin, there was a layer of fat running down the entire side, and an inedible seam of gristle running through the whole steak. It was nicely cooked tho
2 Stars
Was raw in the middle and needed salt
1 Stars
Steak was terrible
3 Stars
Sodium too high
2 Stars
Steak was predominantly grizzle/fat. Potato and broccoli were great though.
3 Stars
Expensive for the quality
2 Stars
The steak was fatty and tough
3 Stars
Meat was blue when I got it definitely needed a longer cook time them instructed, so did potato. (Used oven)
3 Stars
Steak should come more rare so when it is heated it is medium rare not medium to medium well
1 Stars
The piece of steak was a good size. But literally every single piece had 90% cartilage. It wasn't even just fat. That I could deal with. This was not even edible. I fed it to my dogs. I was extremely disappointed and will not be ordering this ever
2 Stars
Again, the steak arrived Medium Well instead of Medium Rare. It looked stiff, so I pressed down on the steak. No give to it. I cut it open. Medium Well. Too hard to eat even after slightly warming it up. Will request a refund.
2 Stars
Last Time I ordered this it was very good .This time the steak was incredibly grizzly
5 Stars
Wow this is delicious, all of it.
1 Stars
For the price, I expected a decent sized steak. It was small and well done when it got to my door, i could tell so I warmed it up only a bit and it was shoe leather. The potato was super small and flavorless.
5 Stars
This steak and baked potato were sooooooooo delicious. The steak was cooked perfectly, and the onion butter is out of this world. Baked potato was creamy and flavorful. Broccoli delicious too!
3 Stars
Lots of fat
3 Stars
The potato was a dismal size. Broccoli bland. I fully expected a microwaved steak to become medium well... but still price does not reflect the quality. Bring it down 5 bucks... then maybe.
2 Stars
The steak didn't seem like high quality meat.
1 Stars
i had the steakhouse dinner last night and it was really horrible. chewy, full of gristle, wilted broccoli, potato worse than from Oivie Garden. Really really bad and i paid almost $20. i like munchery, but that’s it for me for a while.
2 Stars
Extremely tough, had to use a hack saw to cut it
2 Stars
I rarely if ever leave negative reviews. The steak was overcooked and tough to chew. I would not recommend it. Instead I would recommend the Bavette. The potato was on the dry side. Overall I was disappointed with the dish.
3 Stars
Maybe times on directions for doneness, not sure if that's possible.
3 Stars
Too much fat also
5 Stars
Great
1 Stars
Wasn't a strip steak.
3 Stars
Expecting NYstrip got breakfast steak
5 Stars
This is a really yummy (expensive) meal. Very good!!!
4 Stars
The steak had a lot of fat which made it hard to chew. The flavors of the food were excellent
3 Stars
Cut of meat was very fatty.
5 Stars
Excellent steak,very tender and flavorful, nice size. Potato was also excellent, but would have liked a larger portion of broccoli.
2 Stars
Rubbery, fatty, with "grill" marks that look like they were stamped on at the factory. Avoid.
5 Stars
This makes a delicious and satisfying meal. High quality meat and a generous portion. I heat the broccoli briefly in the microwave and put the rest in the oven.
5 Stars
The butter topping for the steak puts this over the top. Great meal!
1 Stars
It was well done and like shoe leather
2 Stars
Last 2 times tough and dry. First couple of times was great.
4 Stars
Decent sized cut. Wish it was cooked to rare, because warming in oven caused it to be overcooked. The butter was a nice touch and the potato was tasty. Also wished there was more broccoli, only 3 small pieces.
3 Stars
Steak tasted good, but definitely was not medium rare...it was slightly pink in the middle. Potato was good, but not full. Not a great value for $19...
5 Stars
Steak is perfectly cooked.
1 Stars
The steak was beyond well-done.
2 Stars
I cut the steak before I warmed it. It was medium well done :( So it was too well done and tough and definitely NOT to my liking. The broccoli arrived too soft (it was soggy when it arrived & BEFORE I warmed it) Will be wanting a refund.
5 Stars
Excellent
3 Stars
The steak was a little fatty. But the potato was de-lish!
2 Stars
The steak was not very well done and the potato had no flavor.
3 Stars
Steak was cut too thin, about 1/2", and came well done. Even with very careful reheating, it was kind of dry. Veggies were OK.
5 Stars
Mmmmmmmmmmmmm tasty
5 Stars
Delicious!
2 Stars
The potato was great! The steak was very thin, poor quality compared to many other steak dishes I've ordered on munchery, and thus a disappointment at $18.
5 Stars
Awesome. Will order again
3 Stars
Too much meat. Recommend smaller portion and lower price
3 Stars
A bit tough in parts, but otherwise very tasty. Loved the potato.
5 Stars
Top quality, tender steak, broccoli cooked just right, and a creamy, cheesy potato. Yum! A little pricy, tho.....
4 Stars
Steak had an excellent taste.
5 Stars
My boyfriend loved this! The butter was sooo good. Definitely worth it.
1 Stars
Such poor quality meat. Super fatty, hardly had any edible meat. Was very dissapointing. Now I'm still hungry after paying for a nice dinner at the end of our week.
5 Stars
This was amazing! Tender steak everything seasoned perfectly! Easy to prep. Highly recommend!
4 Stars
Yummy Great Flavours ! The steak has great flavours , but a tad too much fat . The potato so delicious wish there was more.
5 Stars
perfect! loved everything about this dish--- please offer it more often and I will order it when I see it :)