Skip Navigation

Classic American Potato Salad

yukon gold potatoes, red onion, just mayo
4.0 stars
(134 reviews)
  • Vegetarian
  • No Gluten Added
  • No Dairy Added
  • No Nuts Added
  • No Egg Added
We make this classic summer favorite with Yukon Gold potatoes for a bit of extra flavor, a scattering of diced red onion for kick, dill pickle for a briney edge, and bring it all together with Just Mayo, our favorite mayonnaise.
Ingredients
  • Potatoes
  • Mayonaise (canola oil, water, white distilled vinegar, 2% or less of the following: spice, salt, sugar, lemon juice concentrate, modified food starch, modified food starch, pea protein, fruit and vegetable juice (color), xanthan gum, calcium chloride)
  • Pickle relish
  • Red Onion
  • Dijon Mustard
  • Kosher Salt
  • Old Bay seasoning
  • Black pepper
Nutrition
Servings Per Container: 1.0
Amount Per Serving*
Calories 490
Total Fat 31g
Saturated Fat 1.5g
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg
Sodium 760mg
Total Carbs 46g
Dietary Fiber 3g
Sugars 3g
Protein 3g
*Our nutrition data includes all sauces, dressings, condiments, and garnishes included with a dish. If you have specific concerns about sodium, fat, or overall calories, know that we often serve these items on the side so you can add them to taste or leave them out, if you like.

What People Are Saying

1 Stars
There was some random black thing in it. :/
3 Stars
A number of the potatoes were crunchy.
3 Stars
Too much mayo
3 Stars
Half the potatoes were watery and rubbery. Inedible. The dressing was very good.
1 Stars
Very marginal without much flavor. Undercooked potatoes. In all fairness I grew up with amazing potato salad. Where is the red onion show in the photo?
5 Stars
The best!
4 Stars
While the flavor was very good, some of the potato pieces were undercooked...to the point that they were apple-like to the bite. This dish has a lot of potential, however, if prepared properly.
3 Stars
The potatos were underdone for. My taste
5 Stars
L.O.V.E...some pieces a little too crispy (read not cooked enough), but that didn't stop me from eating it all!
2 Stars
Sadly crispy.
2 Stars
Undercooked potatoes
1 Stars
Taste is fine, but portion is super small for the price. Sides are meant to be shared and this is barely enough for one person.
5 Stars
Best potato salad I've ever had!!!!
1 Stars
75% of the potatoes were raw and crunchy, and the sauce was soupy :(